Why 75% of First-Time Attendees Never Return (And What to Do About It)

S2E02 • Tue, July 8, 2025 • Duration: 45 mins

S2E02 • Tue, July 8, 2025 • Duration: 45 mins

Why 75% of First-Time Attendees Never Return (And What to Do About It)

Three out of four first-time attendees never return. Not because the art isn’t strong, but because the follow-up isn’t built for loyalty. Most arts & cultural organizations are investing in acquisition, but losing the retention game where it matters most: right after the first visit.

In this episode, we explore why timing trumps intention, where most post-show strategies fall short, and how small shifts in behavior can drive long-term impact. If you're ready to increase the number of your first-time attendees that come back, this is the conversation to start with.

Key takeaways you can act on:

  • Why the “second date” is the most important moment in retention strategy
  • How recency shapes return behavior
  • Common mistakes organizations make in post-show follow-up
  • The difference between audience experience vs. organizational workflow
  • Simple, actionable tactics to turn first-time visitors into repeat attendees 

Listen to this episode:


Watch this episode: