What if your strongest season could be the start of something longer? Proctors Collaborative turned a standout Broadway year into new subscribers and more return visits.
|
+22% Revenue in Broadway subscriptions |
+16% Packages Sold in Broadway subscriptions |
|
~$1.7M Above projection of ticketing revenue |
|
The Challenge:
Growing beyond a loyal base
Proctors had strong subscriber renewals but faced stagnant acquisition, creating a need to reach new audiences and build greater loyalty.
With strong titles in the 2025-26 Broadway season, Proctors also wanted to understand how much growth reflected programming versus its marketing efforts.
The load-in for the national tour of Wicked.
The Approach:
More touchpoints, sharper segments, and a new way in
TRG helped strengthen acquisition campaigns through more audience touchpoints, targeted segmentation, and more strategic use of marketing resources.
The team capitalized on strong programming to attract new subscribers and introduce partial-season choose-your-own (CYO) packages for the first time.
Marketing communications also expanded significantly, with tens of thousands more emails sent through more efficient, targeted campaigns.

A performance from Proctors' Season Announcement Bash.
The Results:
More subscribers, more return visits
Subscriptions exceeded targets that already accounted for the strong season lineup. Compared with 2024-25, Broadway subscription revenue rose 22% and packages sold rose 16%, and ticketing revenue finished about $1.7M above projection.
The new partial-season packages successfully attracted new subscribers, while most existing full-season subscribers renewed their full packages.
The share of buyers who came just once fell from 80% in 2023-24 to 72% in 2025-26, reflecting stronger spending and repeat attendance.
More buyers are coming back
Share of buyers who attended only once. Lower is better.
80%
72%
2023-24
2025-26
What could bring more of your audiences back?
Proctors found new ways to turn a strong season into more subscribers and repeat visits. What might the same focus reveal about your audiences?
If you are heading into a strong season, or a quieter one, it helps to know which relationships are driving your revenue and which are slipping away after one visit. Let's look at your data together.
Go deeper. Hear TRG's team on why subscription is a tactic, not the point, in Leading with Frequency, and on bringing first-timers back in One and Done: Why 90% of Arts Audiences Never Come Back.
About Proctors Collaborative
Proctors Collaborative is a nonprofit arts organization based in Schenectady, New York. It brings together three venues in New York's Capital Region: Proctors, Schenectady's historic theater, which opened in 1926; Capital Repertory Theatre (theREP) in Albany; and Universal Preservation Hall in Saratoga Springs.
Alongside its Broadway season, it presents concerts, theater and community events, and runs arts education through the Collaborative School of the Arts.
About the author of this story
Melissa Li is an undergraduate student at the University of Michigan, studying Economics. She is passionate about the arts and their ability to bring communities together, foster creativity, and create meaningful cultural experiences.


